Which US Independent Prep team ranks first for win percentage in 2026?

Shattuck St Mary's 18U Prep ranks #1 of 22 US Independent Prep teams — 84.3% win rate over the last 5 seasons.

How does The Hockey Review rank teams?

THR rankings combine verified player and family reviews, alumni advancement tracked on Elite Prospects, and five seasons of on-ice results. Rankings are recomputed nightly and refreshed each season.

2026 Best Win Percentage in the US Independent Prep

US Independent Prep teams ranked by combined win percentage over their last five active seasons. How THR calculates rankings

Shattuck St Mary's 18U PrepA+

Faribault, MN · ★ 5.0 2 reviews

84.3% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

NorthStar Christian Academy 18U AAAA-

Alexandria, MN ·

78.4% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

Gilmour Academy PrepB+

Gates Mills, OH · ★ 4.0 1 review

67.4% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

Lake Forest AcademyB+

Lake Forest, IL ·

66.8% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

Northwood School PrepA-

Lake Placid, NY ·

65.1% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

Culver Academies PrepB+

Culver, IN ·

63.6% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

American Hockey Academy 18U AAAB

Canton, MA · ★ 4.0 3 reviews

59% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

Shady Side AcademyB-

Pittsburgh, PA ·

58.2% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

Nichols School PrepB

Buffalo, NY ·

51.5% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#10

Bridgton AcademyB-

North Bridgton, ME ·

49% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#11

Wyoming Seminary PrepB-

Wilkes-Barre, PA ·

46.3% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#12

STAR Hockey Academy U17 PrepB-

Kent, WA ·

45.9% win rate over the last 2 seasons

View team →

#13

Lawrenceville SchoolB-

Lawrenceville, NJ ·

45% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#14

Hill SchoolB-

Pottstown, PA ·

43.8% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#15

Hun SchoolC+

Princeton, NJ ·

39.1% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#16

St. Francis PrepC+

Hamburg, NY ·

38.5% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#17

Tahoe Prep Academy 18U AAAB-

South Lake Tahoe, CA · ★ 3.0 2 reviews

37.7% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#18

CDA Hockey Academy U18 PrepC

Coeur d'Alene, ID ·

34% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#19

Hoosac SchoolC

Hoosick, NY ·

30.3% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#20

CDA Hockey Academy U17 PrepC

Coeur d'Alene, ID ·

27% win rate over the last 4 seasons

View team →

#21

Rice Memorial PrepB

South Burlington, VT · ★ 3.7 7 reviews

24.6% win rate over the last 5 seasons

View team →

#22

CDA Hockey Academy U17 VarsityC

Coeur d'Alene, ID ·

21.1% win rate over the last 3 seasons

View team →

Played for one of these programs? Reviews from players and families are what power THR rankings.

Find your team's page and share your experience.

Related rankings

Best Alumni Advancement in the US Independent Prep Most Improved Teams in the US Independent Prep Best US Independent Prep Programs